Baltimore Eggnog in a punch cup dusted with nutmeg

Hot Drink

Baltimore Eggnog

How to make a Baltimore Eggnog - the rich eggnog variation with cognac, rum and Madeira, plus egg, cream and nutmeg. A decadent classic.

15 minPrep time
mediumDifficulty
Punch cupGlass
2Serving(s)

More drinks with Cognac →

The Baltimore Eggnog is the decadent Southern variation of the classic eggnog: cognac, rum and Madeira combine with egg and cream into a particularly rich drink. The triple spirit base gives it a complex, nutty-sweet depth. A classic for festive occasions.

Instructions

  1. Beat the egg yolks with the sugar until creamy.
  2. Stir cognac, rum and Madeira into the yolks.
  3. Add milk and cream and mix well.
  4. Whip the egg whites until stiff and gently fold them in.
  5. Pour into punch cups and dust with nutmeg.

Garnish: Grated nutmeg

Pro tip: The Madeira is what sets this apart from a classic eggnog - it gives the drink a nutty-sweet depth that makes it unmistakable.

Frequently asked questions

What sets the Baltimore Eggnog apart from a regular eggnog?

The Baltimore Eggnog uses a combination of cognac, rum and Madeira, which gives it a particularly rich and complex note.

Can I make the drink without Madeira?

Madeira is the characteristic element; as a substitute, a sweet sherry or port works too.

How many portions does the recipe yield?

The recipe is designed for two portions and can easily be scaled up for a larger group.

Ingredients

  • Eggs (yolk and white separated)2 pieces
  • Sugar3 tbsp
  • Cognac4 cl
  • Dark rum2 cl
  • Madeira2 cl
  • Milk and cream mixed10 cl